Related News

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

April 24, 2025
Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

February 10, 2025
Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

June 13, 2025

Browse by Category

  • Blockchain
  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Entertainment
  • Health Care
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • UK News
  • US News
  • World

Related News

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

April 24, 2025
Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

February 10, 2025
Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

June 13, 2025

Browse by Category

  • Blockchain
  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Entertainment
  • Health Care
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • UK News
  • US News
  • World
IIHS NEWS - AI Curated content
  • Home
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • US News
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health Care
  • Crypto
No Result
View All Result
CONTRIBUTE
IIHS NEWS - AI Curated content
  • Home
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • US News
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health Care
  • Crypto
No Result
View All Result
IIHS NEWS - AI Curated content
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics

Government accused of ‘stark’ contradiction over position on Gaza genocide allegations

Sarah Taylor by Sarah Taylor
June 30, 2025
in Politics, US News, World
0
Government accused of ‘stark’ contradiction over position on Gaza genocide allegations
74
SHARES
1.2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The government has won a long-running legal challenge about its decision to continue allowing the sale of spare parts for F-35 fighter jets to Israel, while suspending other arms licences over concerns about international humanitarian law in Gaza.

You might also like

More than 140 killed or injured in tailgating incidents each year

Israeli PM to meet Donald Trump next week

PM faces threat of major Labour rebellion as key vote on welfare reforms looms

But a key part of its case has highlighted mixed messaging about its position on the risk of genocide in Gaza – and intensified calls for ministers to publish their own assessment on the issue.

PM braced for pivotal vote – politics latest

Lawyers acting for the government told judges “the evidence available does not support a finding of genocide” and “the government assessment was that…there was no serious risk of genocide occurring”.

Therefore, they argued, continuing to supply the F-35 components did not put the UK at risk of breaching the Genocide Convention.

This assessment has never been published or justified by ministers in parliament, despite numerous questions on the issue.

Some MPs argue its very existence contrasts with the position repeatedly expressed by ministers in parliament – that the UK is unable to give a view on allegations of genocide in Gaza, because the question is one for the international courts.

For example, just last week Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner told PMQs “it is a long-standing principle that genocide is determined by competent international courts and not by governments”.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

‘The UK cannot sit on our hands’

Green MP Ellie Chowns said: “The government insists only an international court can judge whether genocide is occurring in Gaza, yet have somehow also concluded there is ‘no serious risk of genocide’ in Gaza – and despite my urging, refuse to publish the risk assessments which lead to this decision.

“Full transparency on these risk assessments should not be optional; it is essential for holding the government to account and stopping further atrocity.

“While Labour tie themselves in knots contradicting each other, families are starving, hospitals lie in ruins, and children are dying.

“The UK cannot sit on our hands waiting for an international court verdict when our legal duty under the Genocide Convention compels us to prevent genocide from occurring, not merely seek justice after the fact.”

Be the first to get Breaking News

Install the Sky News app for free

‘Why are these assessments being made?’

“This contradiction at the heart of the government’s position is stark,” said Zarah Sultana MP, an outspoken critic of Labour’s approach to the conflict in Gaza, who now sits as an independent after losing the party whip last summer.

“Ministers say it’s not for them to determine genocide, that only international courts can do so. Yet internal ‘genocide assessments’ have clearly been made and used to justify continuing arms exports to Israel.

“If they have no view, why are these assessments being made? And if they do, why refuse to share them with parliament? This Labour government, in opposition, demanded the Tories publish their assessments. Now in office, they’ve refused to do the same.”

Read more:
‘All I see is blood’
‘It felt like earthquakes’
MPs want Ukraine-style scheme for Gazans

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Judges at the High Court ultimately ruled the case was over such a “sensitive and political issue” it should be a matter for the government, “which is democratically accountable to parliament and ultimately to the electorate, not the court”.

Dearbhla Minogue, a senior lawyer at the Global Legal Action Network, and a solicitor for Al-Haq, the Palestinian human rights group which brought the case, said: “This should not be interpreted as an endorsement of the government, but rather a restrained approach to the separation of powers.

“The government’s disgraceful assessment that there is no risk of genocide has therefore evaded scrutiny in the courts, and as far as we know it still stands.”

What is the government’s position?

Government lawyers argued the decision not to ban the export of F-35 parts was due to advice from Defence Secretary John Healey, who said a suspension would impact the whole F-35 programme and have a “profound impact on international peace and security”.

The UK supplies F-35 component parts as a member of an international defence programme which produces and maintains the fighter jets. As a customer of that programme, Israel can order from the pool of spare parts.

Labour MP Richard Burgon said the ruling puts the government under pressure to clarify its position.

“This court ruling is very clear: only the government and parliament can decide if F-35 fighter jet parts – that can end up in Israel – should be sold,” he said.

“So the government can no longer pass the buck: it can stop these exports, or it can be complicit in Israel’s genocide in Gaza.

“On many issues they say it’s not for the government to decide, but it’s one for the international courts. This washing of hands will no longer work.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Israel has consistently rejected any allegations of genocide.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu branded a recent UN report on the issue biased and antisemitic.

“Instead of focusing on the crimes against humanity and war crimes committed by the Hamas terrorist organisation… the United Nations once again chooses to attack the state of Israel with false accusations,” he said in a statement.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The UK government has not responded to requests for comment over its contrasting messaging to parliament and the courts over allegations of genocide.

But in response to the judgement, a spokesperson said: “The court has upheld this government’s thorough and lawful decision-making on this matter.

“This shows that the UK operates one of the most robust export control regimes in the world. We will continue to keep our defence export licensing under careful and continual review.

“On day one of this Government, the foreign secretary ordered a review into Israel’s compliance with international humanitarian law (IHL).

“The review concluded that there was a clear risk that UK exports for the IDF (Israel Defence Forces) in the Gaza conflict might be used to commit or facilitate serious violations of IHL.

“In contrast to the last government, we took decisive action, stopping exports to the Israeli Defence Forces that might be used to commit or facilitate serious violations of international humanitarian law in Gaza.”

Read Entire Article
Tags: Skynews
Share30Tweet19
Sarah Taylor

Sarah Taylor

Recommended For You

More than 140 killed or injured in tailgating incidents each year

by Sarah Taylor
July 1, 2025
0
More than 140 killed or injured in tailgating incidents each year

More than 140 people are killed or seriously injured in tailgating incidents in England each year, according to research.

Read more

Israeli PM to meet Donald Trump next week

by Sarah Taylor
July 1, 2025
0
Israeli PM to meet Donald Trump next week

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will be meeting Donald Trump next Monday, according to US officials.

Read more

PM faces threat of major Labour rebellion as key vote on welfare reforms looms

by Sarah Taylor
July 1, 2025
0
PM faces threat of major Labour rebellion as key vote on welfare reforms looms

Sir Keir Starmer continues to face the threat of a major rebellion during a key vote on welfare reforms later - despite making last-minute concessions to disgruntled Labour...

Read more

Stab victim describes horrible reality of knife crime

by Sarah Taylor
July 1, 2025
0
Stab victim describes horrible reality of knife crime

As we pulled back the hospital curtain, he was hunched over and clearly in pain.

Read more

Man to plead guilty to murdering four University of Idaho students

by Sarah Taylor
July 1, 2025
0
Man to plead guilty to murdering four University of Idaho students

The man accused of stabbing four University of Idaho students to death has agreed to plead guilty to the murders, in a move that would spare him from...

Read more
Next Post
Suspect who targeted fire service in ‘ambush’ shooting named as aspiring firefighter

Suspect who targeted fire service in 'ambush' shooting named as aspiring firefighter

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

At least 44 killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza, Hamas-backed health ministry says

April 24, 2025
Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

Super Bowl 2025 – latest updates

February 10, 2025
Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

Ruling over VAT on private school fees ‘huge disappointment’, say campaigners

June 13, 2025

Browse by Category

  • Blockchain
  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Entertainment
  • Health Care
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • UK News
  • US News
  • World
IIHS NEWS – AI Curated content

IIHS.NEWS will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.

CATEGORIES

  • Blockchain
  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Entertainment
  • Health Care
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • UK News
  • US News
  • World

BROWSE BY TAG

Blockchain Breaking News Business Entertainment Health Care Insidebitcoins newsbtc Politico Skynews Techcrunch Technology UK US USMagazine Variety World

© 2025 iihs.news - all rights reserved. YYC TECH CONSULTING.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • US News
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health Care
  • Crypto

© 2025 iihs.news - all rights reserved. YYC TECH CONSULTING.